Two General Index energy analysts, Arran Brodie in Europe and Zul Kader in Asia, reviewed recent developments in the Northwest European and Asia-Pacific LPG markets. Virginia Bridgewater, LPG Pricing Director, and Reza Amanat, Pricing Director for Asia Pacific, joined for the Q&A. Andrew Wheeler, Marketing Manager, moderated. The session was recorded in February 2023.
Northwest Europe: a short-lived supply scare
Arran said General Index assesses the main Northwest European LPG markets, including CIF NWE large cargoes. It recently added a weekly butane barge assessment, chosen because daily spot trading in that market can be very thin. Propane FOB NWE barges and a butane forward curve were in development.
Between January 23 and February 2, 2023, propane large cargo prices rose and then fell by about $125/mt. Spreads between propane and butane and between propane and naphtha spiked and then returned to earlier levels. Arran said the move reflected fear of a supply shortage more than an actual shortage. Asian buyers had increased spot purchases during cold weather and after China lifted Covid restrictions. European buyers pushed up prices to narrow the spread with Asia and keep US cargoes coming to Europe.
Several factors made the market more nervous:
- Lower refinery output: European refiners were producing less LPG because they were prioritizing diesel to replace Russian volumes.
- Less Russian LPG than before: Kpler data shows Russian LPG exports to Northwest Europe had already halved before the war, as more LPG from the Baltic port of Ust-Luga went to Russian petrochemical plants. Arran estimated Europe was losing only 15,000 to 20,000 b/d compared with the previous two years, about 1% of its daily imports.
- Lower Scandinavian exports: These were about 30% below the five-year average, while refinery output there was only about 20% lower. Arran said high natural gas prices made it more profitable to blend LPG into the gas stream than to export it.
- Fewer barges for butane: High gas prices also pushed some European buyers to import ammonia from North Africa. Ammonia moved inland by barge along the Rhine pays better than butane, so fewer barges were available for butane, particularly during strong blending periods.
The Mediterranean and the rise of US supply
Arran said Mediterranean LPG imports used to be split fairly evenly between the US and Norway, which together supplied about two-thirds. Since the US shale boom and the fall in Norwegian exports, the US now supplies almost all of that share. This has changed how Mediterranean cargoes are priced. They were previously priced off CIF ARA large cargoes plus freight, but now depend on destination. Deliveries to Turkey use Sonatrach's monthly price. Deliveries to Morocco use a formula that combines Northwest European coaster prices, Mont Belvieu, and freight from Houston.
Some market participants worry that Europe now relies too heavily on US supply, since Asian buyers often pay more for the same cargoes. New ships may ease some of that pressure. According to Clarksons, 40 very large gas carriers (VLGCs) were due for delivery in 2023, on top of the seven or eight already delivered that year, with 29 more on order for 2024 to 2026.
Asia: China's demand held up
Zul said General Index's Asia-Pacific coverage includes swaps and physical prices for FOB Middle East Gulf and for cargoes delivered to Japan. It recently added full-cargo assessments for deliveries to Japan.
In early 2022, Asian LPG prices tracked crude, and both rose after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. From mid-2022, LPG separated from crude as weak petrochemical margins and high freight rates pulled prices lower. At the end of the year, Asian propane jumped by about $200/mt while crude was falling. Winter Storm Elliott had disrupted US Gulf Coast production, and China ended its zero-Covid policy in December.
Chinese demand stayed stronger than expected in 2022. Imports rose by about 2 million mt to around 26 million mt, supported by about 4 million mt of new propane dehydrogenation (PDH) capacity. That was half the growth of the previous year, when imports rose by 4 million mt. India's import growth also slowed, from 1.6 million mt in 2021 to 600,000 mt in 2022. Another 9.5 million mt of petrochemical capacity, including 8.1 million mt of PDH, was planned in China for 2023, though not all of it may be built.
US exports to Asia fell by about 2 million mt a year as more US cargoes went to Europe. Exports from the Middle East Gulf to Asia rose by about 4 million mt, with Iran accounting for more than half of the increase. US propane stocks were above their five-year average in 2022, although EIA data showed six straight weekly draws at the time of recording.
Zul expected four factors to shape the Asian market:
- freight rates and Panama Canal delays
- the risk of recession in major economies, which could slow demand growth in China and India
- Europe competing with Asia for LNG and LPG as it replaces Russian supply
- rapid petrochemical capacity growth in China, which could squeeze margins
Audience questions
On the weekly butane assessment, Virginia said daily butane barge trading is patchy and depends on blending demand. A weekly average of trades, or of bids and offers when there are no trades, gives a more accurate picture.
On Scandinavian output, she said producers were still blending LPG into the gas stream even after gas prices eased, and their other reasons were not clear.
Asked about Chinese demand after the end of zero-Covid, Zul said the planned capacity would need healthy petrochemical margins. In a global recession, there would be too many downstream products and LPG demand would weaken.
On VLGC freight, Reza said the planned petrochemical capacity in China and slower sailing speeds to cut emissions would both support freight rates. He added that the eastern and western fleets are largely separate. Few European ports can take VLGCs, and Virginia noted that this has long complicated the TOTSA cargo contract. Reza said more Asian ports can now receive full VLGCs, which is why General Index launched its full-cargo Japan assessments.
Watch the full webinar below.

.png)
.webp)









